hirly

Priority One Payroll

Payroll Specialist

Malta, New York

See how you match this job — and similar ones. Free.

Upload your resume and hirly scores it against this role at Priority One Payroll first, then against similar open jobs, and shows where you fit and why.

PDF or DOCX, up to 12MB. No sign-up to see your matches.

Get past the screening software and onto a recruiter's desk

hirly rewrites your resume for this job — matching the keywords and skills in the posting, moving your most relevant experience to the top, and writing a cover letter to fit. About 30 seconds.

  • Keywords matched to this posting
  • Fit score before you apply
  • Cover letter included
Tailor my resume for this job →

Apply from your AI assistant

Connect hirly to Claude and ask it to apply to this job. hirly tailors your resume, fills the employer’s form and asks before sending. ChatGPT: manual setup today.

Some employer sites stop an application at a CAPTCHA or sign-in and hand it back with a link. Applying needs a paid plan. Works with any assistant that supports MCP.

hirly's read of this role

Seniority
Mid level
Country
US
Work mode
On-site / unstated
First seen by hirly
23 Oct 2026

Derived automatically from the posting. Upload your resume above to see how the role scores against it.

the posting

Priority One Payroll is looking for a motivated and eager individual who is looking to become part of our payroll customer service team.

To be successful in this role, you will need prior payroll experience, attention to detail, excellent phone skills as well as the ability to work in a team environment. Your positive attitude and mix of initiative and team mindedness will help you fit in on day one. You will have an opportunity to grow with the company and provide crucial payroll compliance expertise and customer support.

A day in the life of one of our Payroll Customer Service Specialists is one filled with variety and an extensive amount of attention to detail. In this position, you will be interfacing with approximately 250 clients and supporting them with a high level of customer service every day. The customer service experience is what has made Priority One Payroll continue to grow and be successful.

Company Summary

Priority One Payroll is the premier New York Capital District small business payroll outsourcing company.

Priority One Payroll delivers tailored payroll services designed to meet the individual needs of every client, from complete payroll tax preparation and administration, to services including direct deposit, garnishment service, benefit time accrual, workers’ compensation insurance , time and attendance solutions , 401k offerings and much more.

With superior customer service and a state-of-the-art payroll platform, Priority One Payroll provides the best of both worlds: great service at a great price.

Position Summary

Reporting to the Operations Manager, the Payroll Specialist is ultimately responsible for ensuring the customers’ expectations of a payroll job well done are met, compliantly and without defect. Success in this role requires an unusual balance of Payroll lifecycle expertise, attention to detail and the empathy typically reserved for only the best customer service team members.

The exceptional rapport built, and attention to detail demonstrated through the Payroll Specialists, across the client portfolio, is what continues to drive Priority One Payroll’s success.

How You’ll Make an Impact

Become an expert in payroll set-up (documentation & data systems), execution and reporting, customer service, and associated regulatory guidelines

Build trust across the client portfolio by demonstrating a detailed understanding of not only payroll but ACH/banking processes, workers compensation, disability, and paid family leave, etc.

Serve as the main point of contact for the client(s) and deliver an outstanding customer experience

Deliver error-free, first time every time success while gracefully managing all client concerns to a successful close

Operate within and continually improve the associated business processes and work instructions

What You Must Bring to This Role

Associate’s degree in Finance, Accounting, Business or related, or a High School Diploma/GED and 4 years related experience or training in the Payroll lifecycle - required

History of success operating in Payroll or a similar Human Resource or Accounting roles - required

History in customer facing roles - required

Demonstrated success rapidly building and maintaining relationships within an organization - required

A history of excellence in communication (verbal and written), active listening, overcoming objections, risk mitigation, and problem-solving - required

Exceptionally high attention to detail demonstrated - required

Proven ability to manage multiple projects/priorities at the same time while prioritizing deliverables day-to-day - required

A desire to continue learning, and proven success learning and translating learning into practice and results -required

Demonstrated mastery responding to questions in a tactful & professional manner - required

Strong interpersonal skills & the ability to effectively work with a wide range of individuals - required

Working knowledge of Microsoft Office or Google Suite - required

Working knowledge of Execupay, PlatinumPay, Xpress, and SwipeClock software or similar - desired

  • Fundamental Payroll Certification or Certified Payroll Professional Certification - desired
  • note: Priority One Payroll will pay for the certification exam every 3 years. A $1,000.00 bonus will be paid for the first certification only.

Compensation, Benefits & Fun Stuff

Company paid PTO

6 Paid Company Holidays

401k with Profit Sharing

Group Long Term Disability and Life Insurance

100% Employee (Single Only) Paid Health Insurance and Health Savings Plan

Vision and Dental Insurance

Working Conditions & Physical Efforts

Work is performed in an office work environment

May be required to lift up to 30 lbs.

Ability to sit for a prolonged period of time

Visual functions being those of near vision, depth perception, and ability to adjust focus

Talking and hearing occur continuously in the process of communicating with leadership & client businesses

Transportation to & from work locations

Finger dexterity is needed to access, enter, and retrieve data using a computer keyboard or operate equipment

No or very limited exposure to physical risk

This role is posted in partnership with HR Resolved, Inc.

Original posting on Priority One Payroll's site ↗

Listed on hirly, a job board. hirly is not the employer: Priority One Payroll is hiring for this role.

Browse similar roles

Want this one?

Upload your resume and hirly rewrites it for this job and writes the cover letter — in about thirty seconds, before you sign up.

Tailor my resume for this job