Pie Insurance
Senior Manager, Claims Vendor Management
United States
hirly Pro
Get in front of the people hiring at Pie Insurance
- Reach the hiring manager at Pie Insurance on LinkedIn, from your own account
- hirly applies to this job for you, with unlimited applications
- A resume and cover letter written for this job, unlimited
- The hiring manager and recruiter at Pie Insurance, with contact details
$49 a month · ₹1,999 for 30 days in India · cancel any time
Get past the screening software and onto a recruiter's desk
hirly rewrites your resume for this job — matching the keywords and skills in the posting, moving your most relevant experience to the top, and writing a cover letter to fit. About 30 seconds.
- Keywords matched to this posting
- Fit score before you apply
- Cover letter included
Matched against 2.1M live jobs from 220,000+ employers in 190+ countries.
Tailor my resume for this job →Apply from your AI assistant
Connect hirly to Claude or ChatGPT and ask it to apply to this job. hirly tailors your resume, fills the employer’s form and asks before sending.
Some employer sites stop an application at a CAPTCHA or sign-in and hand it back with a link. Applying needs a paid plan. Works with any assistant that supports MCP.
hirly's read of this role
- Role family
- Supply chain
- Seniority
- Lead / management
- Stated salary
- $130,000 – $160,000 per year
- Country
- US
- Work mode
- On-site / unstated
- First seen by hirly
- 16 Oct 2026
Derived automatically from the posting. Upload your resume above to see how the role scores against it.
the posting
Pie's mission is to empower small businesses to thrive by making commercial insurance affordable and as easy as pie. We leverage technology to transform how small businesses buy and experience commercial insurance.
Like our small business customers, we are a diverse team of builders, dreamers, and entrepreneurs who are driven by core values and operating principles that guide every decision we make.
The Senior Manager, Claims Vendor Management will establish and lead Pie's comprehensive Claims Vendor Management program for all strategic claims vendors, with significant responsibility for oversight of high-risk managed care program vendors. This role oversees the full spectrum of Claims vendor relationships including managed care services (medical bill review, pharmacy benefit management, utilization review, provider networks), legal vendors (law firms and litigation support), investigative services, support vendors (transportation, translation), and API-integrated technology vendors. The Senior Manager is responsible for developing and executing a comprehensive vendor strategy, including implementing a sunset program to eliminate redundant contracts, establishing a formal RFP process for competitive vendor selection, and leading contract negotiations and renegotiations to optimize value and performance across all vendor categories. This role requires exceptional relationship management skills, advanced analytical capabilities to identify cost reduction opportunities, and the ability to collaborate across Claims, Legal, Finance, and Procurement to drive vendor performance improvements and ensure compliance with billing practices.
How You'll Do It
Vendor Management Program Development
Establish and implement a comprehensive Claims Vendor Management program for Pie's strategic claims vendors
Develop and lead vendor management strategy for the Claims Department in partnership with Claims leadership
Build and manage a vendor management team to support strategic initiatives, including leadership oversight of direct reports
Create and maintain a centralized repository of all vendor contracts with visibility across departments
Implement vendor performance management frameworks and accountability structures
Develop policies, procedures, and work plans that affect the department and may have company-wide impact
Managed Care Vendor Oversight
Provide high-level oversight of critical managed care program vendors with significant focus on medical bill review, pharmacy benefit management, utilization review, and provider networks
Ensure managed care vendors deliver quality services that support medical cost containment objectives
Monitor compliance with contractual obligations and service level agreements for high-risk managed care vendor relationships
Collaborate with Senior Director, Managed Care Services on vendor strategy and performance
Assess vendor performance impact on medical loss costs and claim outcomes
Lead initiatives to optimize managed care vendor portfolios and drive cost savings
Comprehensive Vendor Portfolio Management
Oversee all Claims vendor categories including legal vendors (law firms and litigation support), investigative services, support vendors (transportation, translation), and API-integrated technology vendors
Develop vendor management strategies tailored to the unique requirements of each vendor category
Balance strategic focus on high-impact managed care vendors while maintaining effective oversight of all other vendor types
Ensure consistent application of vendor management standards across diverse vendor categories
Coordinate vendor relationships to support seamless Claims operations and optimal outcomes
Strategic Vendor Initiatives
Implement a sunset program to identify and eliminate redundant or underperforming vendor contracts across all vendor categories
Establish and manage a formal RFP process to ensure competitive and transparent vendor selection
Lead contract negotiations, renewals, and renegotiations to drive cost savings and improved terms for Pie
Develop sourcing strategies in collaboration with internal Claims leadership to achieve cost reductions
Analyze internal vendor costs against market forces to reduce Pie's claim costs and gain competitive advantages
Drive strategy and success of larger vendor initiatives that contribute to multiple areas of the organization
Vendor Performance Management
Set up and facilitate quarterly or annual meetings with Claims and vendor executives across all vendor categories to discuss performance and action items
Collect and collate vendor performance feedback and review vendor spend and billing practices for managed care, legal, investigative, support, and technology vendors
Establish KPIs to monitor vendor performance and ensure accountability and continuous improvement across all vendor types
Perform vendor billing audits and lead vendor spend reviews to identify incorrect billing practices
Serve as the central point of contact for strategic claims vendors across all categories
Process Improvement & Compliance
Lead the transition of vendors to improved billing and bulk billing practices
Implement agreed plans with Claims leadership to optimize billing processes
Ensure compliance with billing practices and enterprise standards
Partner with Claims leadership, Legal, Finance, and Procurement to ensure alignment and compliance
Demonstrate project management skills to drive vendor management initiatives and provide regular updates
Cross-Functional Collaboration
Collaborate with cross-functional teams to support product launches, operational needs, and strategic goals
Partner with Claims Operations, Regulatory Compliance, and Claims Adjudication teams on vendor-related matters
Work closely with Finance on budget management and cost containment initiatives
Coordinate with Legal on contract reviews, negotiations, and compliance matters
The Right Stuff
Required Experience & Education
Bachelor's degree in Business Administration, Finance, Supply Chain Management, or related field; Master's degree preferred
10+ years of experience in vendor management, procurement, or strategic sourcing
5+ years of experience in insurance industry, preferably in claims operations or vendor management
3+ years of people management experience, including oversight of managers or team leads
Proven track record of leading vendor contract negotiations and achieving significant cost savings
Experience developing and implementing vendor management programs from the ground up
Strong understanding of workers' compensation and managed care vendors landscape, as well as legal, investigative, and support vendor categories; experience with commercial auto vendors is a plus
Deep expertise in managed care services including medical bill review, pharmacy benefit management, utilization review, and provider networks
Knowledge of legal vendor management including law firm relationships and litigation support services
Understanding of investigative services, transportation, translation, and other ancillary claims support vendors
Experience managing API-integrated technology vendors and understanding system integration requirements
Strategic & Analytical Expertise
Advanced analytical skills with ability to evaluate vendor performance data, identify cost reduction opportunities, and apply conceptual thinking to complex organizational objectives
Experience conducting vendor billing audits and comprehensive spend analysis across multiple vendor categories
Strong understanding of RFP processes, contract negotiation strategies, and vendor selection criteria for both operational and managed care vendors
Ability to benchmark vendor costs against market rates and industry standards
Experience developing and implementing sunset programs for vendor portfolio op
Listed on hirly, a job board. hirly is not the employer: Pie Insurance is hiring for this role.
Similar jobs
- Vehicle Logistics Planning ManagerSubaru · Camden, NJ, United StatesFirst seen today
- SCM Category Manager - Enterprise ServicesSouthern Company · Atlanta, GA, United States; Birmingham, AL, United StatesFirst seen today
- Supply Chain District/Area Manager I (West Texas – Odessa)Nabors · Odessa, TX, United StatesFirst seen today
- Senior Manager, Procurement OperationsNavy Federal Credit Union · Vienna, VA, United StatesFirst seen today
- Manager/in Batterieökosystem (w/m/d)ZVEI e. V. · Berlin, GermanyFirst seen today
Browse similar roles
Want this one?
Upload your resume and hirly rewrites it for this job and writes the cover letter — in about thirty seconds, before you sign up.
Tailor my resume for this job